Home / Year-wise PYQ / July 2016 (II) / Truth of the statement is not a defence against

Truth of the statement is not a defence against

Truth of the statement is not a defence against

(A) defamation

(B) breach of privilege

(C) official secret violation

(D) contempt of court

Correct Ans: (D)

Explanation:
Courts treat contempt cases differently from other legal matters. Even if a statement is true, courts may still see it as contempt. This happens when the statement damages the courtโ€™s authority or public confidence in it.

Contempt law protects the integrity of the judiciary. Truth alone doesn’t justify speech that insults or weakens a courtโ€™s image. The Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 allows truth as a defence only if it meets two conditions: it must serve the public interest and must be made in good faith.

In contrast:

  • (A) Defamation allows truth as a full defence if it benefits the public.
  • (B) Breach of privilege involves rules of Parliament or press, where truth may still not help.
  • (C) Official secrets law punishes unauthorized disclosures, regardless of truth.

So, truth doesnโ€™t automatically protect someone from contempt charges. The court focuses on intent and effect, not just accuracy. This makes (D) Contempt of Court the correct answer.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More to read

About JMC Study Hub

JMC Study Hub is India’s first largest and dedicated learning platform of Journalism and Mass Communication.ย 

Email : support@jmcstudyhub.com

Latest Post
Interview

เคฎเฅˆเค‚ เคคเฅ‹ เค•เฅ‡เคตเคฒ เคฆเฅ‚เคฐเคฆเคฐเฅเคถเคจ เคฆเฅ‡เค–เคคเคพ เคนเฅ‚เค‚, เคฌเคกเคผเฅ€ เคถเคพเค‚เคคเคฟ เคธเฅ‡ เคฌเคพเคค เค•เคฐเคคเฅ‡ เคนเฅˆเค‚- เคตเคฟเค•เคพเคธ เคฎเคฟเคถเฅเคฐเคพ

Interview- Dr. Surendra

เคธเคพเคฎเฅเคฆเคพเคฏเคฟเค• เคฐเฅ‡เคกเคฟเคฏเฅ‹ เคนเคฐ เคชเฅเคฐเค•เคพเคฐ เค•เฅ€ เคธเคฎเคธเฅเคฏเคพเค“เค‚ เค•เคพ เคธเคฎเคพเคงเคพเคจ เค•เคฐเคคเคพ เคนเฅˆ- เคกเฅ‰. เคธเฅเคฐเฅ‡เค‚เคฆเฅเคฐ

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Quick Revision
FOLLOW US ON FACEBOOK
error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top